Pages

    Saturday, May 24, 2008

    Decision

    It's been a while since we've updated. Sadly, the silence is mostly an indication of us not doing much on the home front. We've been insanely busy with work, but occasionally we have a moment to ponder how little we want to stay in this current condo long term!

    With that in mind, we've made a bit of a decision. We're no longer eyeing lots in any type of historic preservation district, which includes our current neighborhood. It hit me one afternoon that I didn't want a board of strangers telling us what we could or could not do with a particular piece of property.* There are fewer things that make me grumpier faster than thinking about the Historic Landmarks Commission.

    * And yes, I know that this grouchy libertarian rant doesn't take into account all the good things that zoning has brought this world, nor the positive achievements of cities — and Salt Lake City, in particular — such as the roads I drive, the power lines I use, the water lines that slake my thirst, et cetera, et cetera.

    That's the short story.

    The medium story is that I called a SLC planning employee to ask about a particular, reasonably-priced property in our neighborhood. This piece of property has a nearly condemned home on it, making it — so I thought — a ripe candidate for a tear-down. The planner stated in no uncertain terms that she would never try to tear down a building in a historic preservation district. She almost laughed when I pointed out that the building wasn't a contributing structure, that it was in really bad shape, hadn't been occupied, was nearing the point when you can call the city to request that it board up the home, etc. Evidently, even the planners in the city recognize that the HLC doesn't play that way.

    The HLC has absolute power over tear-downs in historic preservation districts. In order to tear down anything in that district, you must prove economic hardship, which is a subjective term with jurisdiction for that decision residing solely with the HLC. In short, the HLC does not want you to tear down anything in a preservation district.

    With the rest of what we've heard about the HLC, the variances that they would have to approve in order for us to build on any lot in this area, and the grumpiness I feel about these guys in general, something clicked. I just didn't want to deal with it any more. I didn't want to have to pep talk myself into the fight it would take to build modern in this area. I love this neighborhood, but...my love has its limits.

    So, wherever you are, nameless planner in the depths of the City-County building, this post goes out to you. Thanks for setting me right. We're now looking at neighborhoods near Liberty Park, just south of downtown, safely outside Salt Lake's historic preservation zones and near a couple of streets where a few other modern homes have popped up in the last year or so.

    Oh, and I promise to hound Tai to show you all what he's done with the fireplace, book shelf, and mantle.

    4 comments:

    April said...

    I'm sorry to hear things won't work out the way you had hoped. Good luck as you move forward with the new plan!

    Anonymous said...

    Do you mean Liberty Park as in high crime rate, scarry people Liberty Park? JK I'm sure there are some very nice neighborhoods around. My only experience in the area was feeding the homeless under the Viaduct on Sunday mornings and holidays. Lots of Women and children in the breakfast lines too. It would be nice to see the area revived. I'm anxious to see it.

    Noreen

    Tai said...

    I think you may be thinking of Pioneer Park, which is still a hole with homeless drugged out people that use the entire outdoors as their bathroom. Once they move all the homeless services away from there, which is probably inevitable, Pioneer Park could be a nice area too.

    Liberty Park is off of 700 East and 900 South. There really isn't a viaduct near there. The area has actually been on the upswing for the past 6 or 7 years. It would still be a little bit pioneering out there, but I think that the area could catch up.

    April said...

    Are you sure you wouldn't rather move to Rose Park? We really like it here, and we'd love to have you as neighbors!